UAE: Lana Nusseibeh’s UN Candidacy Raises Questions of Accountability and Independence
The nomination of Lana Zaki Nusseibeh by the United Arab Emirates (UAE) for the position of United Nations Secretary-General raises fundamental questions regarding the independence, commitment to human rights and accountability expected of the holder of the Organization’s highest office.
Given her decade-long role as the UAE’s Permanent Representative to the United Nations, her candidacy warrants careful scrutiny in light of documented concerns relating to the UAE’s domestic human rights record and its conduct abroad. Any assessment of her suitability for the role should consider not only her diplomatic experience, but also her commitment to accountability, the protection of human rights, and the consistent application of international law.
Background
On 21 October, the UAE officially announced Nusseibeh’s candidacy in a letter from its President to the Presidents of the General Assembly and the Security Council. She served as the UAE’s Permanent Representative to the United Nations from 2013 to 2024 before assuming ministerial responsibilities. Her record as the government’s senior diplomatic representative at the UN is relevant to assessing how she has addressed human rights concerns involving the UAE and how she would approach such matters if entrusted with leading the organization.
Institutional Position
The cases documented in the UAE, Sudan, Yemen and Libya are relevant to scrutiny of this nomination not simply because they concern the policies of the government Nusseibeh represented, but because they raise substantive questions about how she would approach human rights protection and accountability as Secretary-General. Her long diplomatic tenure at the United Nations makes her public record and stated positions on these matters particularly pertinent to understanding how she would respond when international scrutiny conflicts with the interests of a Member State.
The “UAE 84” proceedings and the continued imprisonment of human rights defender Ahmed Mansoor provide a direct test of the UAE’s stated commitment to human rights. Restrictions on defendants’ access to legal representation and case files, concerns over the fairness of the proceedings, and Mansoor’s prolonged imprisonment for his human rights activities warrant a clear response from a candidate seeking to lead an institution mandated to promote human rights and fundamental freedoms. General assurances of commitment cannot substitute for addressing the substance of these cases.
The documented record concerning the UAE’s role in Sudan, Yemen and Libya raises a related question: whether international accountability mechanisms would receive consistent support when investigations concern powerful states or their partners. The evidence and findings in these cases require careful, independent assessment, including consideration of the UAE’s denials concerning Sudan. The relevant standard for UN leadership is not prejudgment of responsibility, but a demonstrated commitment to impartial investigations, respect for international law and accountability wherever credible evidence warrants it.
Nusseibeh should address these matters publicly and specifically, including the “UAE 84” case, Mansoor’s imprisonment, and investigations into alleged UAE-linked violations abroad. Member States should examine her stated positions alongside her diplomatic record rather than treating seniority or experience within the UN system as sufficient evidence of her approach to human rights. The selection process should give meaningful weight to how candidates intend to protect the independence of UN human rights mechanisms and ensure that political influence does not shield any state from scrutiny.
Documented Human Rights Concerns
· The “UAE 84” Case and Ahmed Mansoor: The “UAE 84” mass trial involved human rights defenders and political dissidents, including individuals already serving lengthy prison sentences. Available documentation has highlighted restrictions on access to legal counsel and case files, secrecy surrounding proceedings, credible allegations of torture and ill-treatment, and concerns regarding the retrial of individuals for the same underlying acts. In March, convictions against 53 defendants were upheld. In June, another 24 defendants were convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment, bringing the total number of defendants sentenced to life imprisonment to 67.
Ahmed Mansoor was arrested in March 2017 and sentenced in 2018 to ten years in prison for his human rights work. In July 2024, he received an additional 15-year sentence, upheld in March 2025 as part of the mass trial. UN experts and human rights organizations have documented his prolonged solitary confinement and harsh detention conditions. His immediate and unconditional release, along with that of all those detained solely for peacefully exercising their rights, remains essential.
· Sudan: Concerns have been documented over the Emirati support for the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), which has been accused of war crimes and crimes against humanity, including mass killings, sexual violence and ethnic persecution. Investigations found that weapons used by the RSF were almost certainly re-exported to Sudan through the UAE in violation of the UN arms embargo, while reports also linked Emirati facilities and an Abu Dhabi-based company to the deployment of Colombian fighters in Sudan. The UAE denies providing military support to any party in the conflict. The International Court of Justice dismissed Sudan’s case against the UAE in May 2025 on jurisdictional grounds without addressing the merits. Independent investigations and accountability remain essential wherever evidence establishes responsibility.
· Yemen: Over the past decade, arbitrary detention, enforced disappearance and torture have been documented in detention facilities operated by Emirati and UAE-backed Yemeni forces in southern Yemen. Concerns have also been raised over the use of counterterrorism as a pretext for detention outside judicial oversight, torture and intimidation of detainees’ families. Investigations into violations that may amount to war crimes, disclosure of the fate of the disappeared, independent monitoring of detention facilities, accountability for perpetrators and reparations for victims remain essential.
· Libya: A field investigation concluded that a UAE drone strike on the Al-Sunbula Factory in November 2019 killed eight civilians and injured 27 others, and found that the attack appeared unlawful. The investigation also examined the UAE’s transfer of weapons to forces loyal to Khalifa Haftar in violation of the UN arms embargo. These findings warrant continued scrutiny and investigation into civilian harm and potential violations of international law.
Applicable International Human Rights and Legal Standards
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights protects freedom of expression, liberty and security of person, fair-trial rights and the right to an effective remedy under Articles 19, 9, 14 and 2(3), respectively. The Convention against Torture prohibits torture and requires effective investigation of credible allegations. International humanitarian law protects civilians during armed conflict and restricts attacks to lawful military objectives. Applicable UN arms embargoes impose obligations that must be respected. These standards are relevant both to the documented cases and to the expectation that UN leadership support impartial monitoring, investigation and accountability.
Demands Aligned with International Human Rights Principles
|
Demand |
Relevant International Human Rights Standard |
|
Member States should subject Nusseibeh’s candidacy to transparent scrutiny and require clear public positions on the “UAE 84” case, Ahmed Mansoor’s imprisonment and alleged UAE-linked violations abroad. |
UN Charter; principles of impartiality, accountability and respect for human rights |
|
Release Ahmed Mansoor and all those detained solely for the peaceful exercise of their rights; ensure fair proceedings, access to legal counsel and humane detention conditions. |
ICCPR Articles 7, 9, 14 and 19; Convention against Torture |
|
Support independent investigations into alleged UAE-linked arms transfers, financing and foreign-fighter deployments in Sudan, and alleged violations in Yemen and Libya. |
International humanitarian law; applicable UN arms embargoes |
|
Disclose the fate and whereabouts of forcibly disappeared people in Yemen, independently monitor detention facilities, investigate allegations of torture and arbitrary detention, and provide victims with effective remedies and reparations. |
ICCPR Articles 2(3), 7 and 9; Convention against Torture; applicable international law |
The Secretary-General must be able to uphold the UN’s principles consistently, including when scrutiny concerns influential Member States. Diplomatic experience alone cannot answer the questions raised by these cases. Member States should ensure that the selection process gives due weight to candidates’ demonstrated commitment to human rights, independent investigations and accountability.
Women Journalists Without Chains
Geneva, Switzerland – October 29, 2026

En
Ar
